After researching online we decided on the 2012 Honda Fit as a second vehicle. We use it primarily as a commuter car - where it excels. It has great handling, can fit two young children in the back with no problem and is easy on gas.
Also, for a little car it has tons of cargo space.

The only down side is that the road noise can be a little loud.

We have had ours for several months and are still happy with it.