2026 BMW M240i Review
Trader scores
This score is awarded by our team of expert reviewers after extensive testing of the car.
Sport compact cars live and die on their ability to convince you to make a bad decision.
Not every car approaches this challenge in the same way. Some appeal to raw desire while others seek to be just reasonable enough to persuade you that they could fit into your life without too many sacrifices (never mind the low resale values, cramped confines, and big gas bills). Whereas the hardcore M2 goes the first route, the more reasonably priced and comfortable 2026 BMW M240i goes the second and makes a remarkably compelling case for itself.
Power 7/10
Power comes from BMW’s venerable inline-six cylinder engine. Down a turbocharger from the wild M2, it’s unsurprising that the M240i is also down on power. While the former makes 473 hp, the latter makes 382 hp — and that’s still plenty. (The four-cylinder 230i xDrive, meanwhile, makes 255 hp). The M240i also makes less power than most competitors, with the likes of the Mercedes-AMG CLA 45, the Audi RS 3, the related Toyota GR Supra, and the Ford Mustang all getting closer to the 400 hp mark, or exceeding it.
Crucially, though, the M240i gets 369 lb-ft of torque, which is a match or better than most of the aforementioned cars. That means when you stomp on the accelerator, you get launched into the back of your seat with striking urgency.
Efficiency 8/10
The relatively modest power figure also means that the M240i drinks less fuel than any of those competitors. Historically, fuel cost hasn’t been a major concern for enthusiasts, but with the current price of gas (premium fuel in most cases, including this one), the BMW’s rating of 9.0 L/100 km combined should result in welcome savings compared to its competitors. Even the Supra, which also uses a BMW-sourced straight-six, consumes more fuel, according to Natural Resources Canada (NRCan), with its rating of 9.4 combined.
Everyday Usability 8/10
And that gets at one of the M240i’s biggest strengths: it’s an excellent compromise. In addition to being able to launch you into your seat, it also offers a 390-L trunk, which is better than any other model in this class, apart from the CLA 45 and, more importantly, it feels like plenty. It is, simply put, a useful trunk in which all your groceries or a weekend’s worth of luggage — or even some moderately sized packages — will fit.
It’s also worth noting that, despite looking tiny, the rear seats are large enough to fit an adult. Admittedly, it’s tight, but I didn’t feel as guilty asking a friend to sit back there as I expected, nor as I would have assuredly felt asking them to squeeze into the back of a Mustang or a Supra. This M240i certainly isn’t a family car, but it’s not ridiculous to think that it could fit into your day to day life, especially as a second vehicle.
Comfort 8/10
In fact, if we ignore gas prices, this car would make a killer commuter. The front seats offer plenty of support and adjustability (as well as two memory settings), the rear seats are acceptable, and, in comfort mode, the suspension softens nicely, allowing it to glide smoothly over uneven pavement and potholed streets without breaking your back.
Equipment 8/10
The M240i also gets a nice mix of fancy pants features and sporty add-ons that make it feel appropriately performance-oriented and luxurious. From an adaptive M suspension ($1,000) that helps this car better manage the competing needs of comfort and performance to surround-view cameras ($1,000) to help with parking, a reasonably large sunroof, heated steering wheel, and lumbar support that are part of the $2,700 Premium Essential package — not to mention standard all-wheel drive — it’s all enough to make this feel like a car that could take on any season.
On the performance side, the $3,000 M performance exhaust that was equipped to this tester sounds positively menacing during cold starts, but mellows out once everything warms up so you aren’t making a spectacle of yourself everywhere you go. M Sport brakes (part of the $900 M Sport Pro package) help stop this car with ferocity, though I found them difficult to modulate at low speed. The M Enhanced Track package includes the adaptive suspension, as well as attractive 19-inch wheels, and adds the M Technology package, which helps the brakes stay cool for longer.
The one feature the M240i doesn’t have is a manual transmission. While three-pedal setups are becoming rarer every day, this is the one segment where the option is still relatively common. The Mustang, Nissan Z, and, most frustratingly of all, closely related Supra and BMW M2 all give drivers the option to shift their own gears. Particularly in this application, where outright racetrack pace takes a back seat to lower speed silliness and on-road entertainment, a manual transmission would suit the character of the car perfectly.
Driving Feel 7/10
A manual transmission would also help the M240i feel a little more engaging to drive. While this car is a pleasure to control, and although it is extremely capable, it suffers from the same numbness as many other high-performance BMWs. A steering wheel that feels large in the hands and an electric power steering system that allows almost no feedback through it makes the M240i feel less playful than its competitors.
However, the steering ratio is quick, so the front end feels very eager to turn in, making even slow-speed corners urgent and energetic. A slightly softer suspension than the ones installed under full-on M cars also gives the driver a little more feedback through the seat. Combined with the ample power provided by the straight-six, and the snappy shifts of the eight-speed transmission, this car is anything but dull to drive, even if there are areas in which it could improve.
Design 8/10
BMW is quickly moving away from one of its most controversial eras of design and that’s a good thing, even though the 2 Series Coupé will likely be remembered as one of the highlights of the time and, of them, I think this M240i is the most attractive. While the triangular side intakes at the front are a little less cohesive than the big squares on the M2, they help the M240i look a little less monolithic and little more conventional. An appropriately-size grille also harkens back to some of BMW’s most venerated designs, and the long hood and short rear combine to create an attractive silhouette.
A rich variety of paint colours, including the Thundernight Metallic purple paint ($900) that caught the attention of everyone I drove past in this test car also help M240i be as expressive or as subtle as its buyer wants it to be. Inside, the design is unspectacular, but nice. A mix of quality materials and a reasonably wide variety of colourways brighten up the cabin.
User Friendliness 6.5/10
Despite not being that old, the 2 Series coupe still uses a curved display that’s on its way out of the BMW lineup. Even so, the 12.3-inch driver display and its 14.9-inch infotainment screen still look impressive. They’re also reasonably responsive to inputs, but the option to use a scroll wheel mounted on the centre console compromises usability, forcing user experience designers to create a touchscreen that isn’t touch-first. In combination with the dearth of physical controls, the system is heavily reliant on menus, which makes it hard to operate on the move.
Safety 7/10
BMW has made some helpful safety technology standard equipment here. All drivers benefit from warnings if they are about to exit their lane, if a vehicle is crossing their path as they reverse, if a front collision is imminent, and if they’re exceeding the speed limit. It will attempt to avert a front-end collision with automatic emergency braking.
Value for Money 8/10
As with many German cars, it’s easy to add significantly to the cost of the M240i if you aren’t careful with the options. This tester featured more than $17,000 in extras, which is — and there’s no other way to put this — a lot.
However, with a starting price of $62,900 (a price that includes the big driver display, heated front seats, automatic high-beams, automatic climate control, as well as an M Sport differential and suspension), the M240i is pretty reasonably priced.
That’s $3,500 less than the cheapest six-cylinder Supra and $19,000 less than an Audi RS 3 (pricing for the Mercedes-AMG CLA 45 was not available at time of writing). In fact, it’s around the same price as an Audi S3, which makes significantly less power (while also consuming more fuel). Sure, the Ford Mustang and the Nissan Z offer more power for less money, but they offer significantly differing levels of luxury and brand cachet, too.
The Verdict
By no means a cheap car, the 2026 BMW M240i isn’t an especially expensive one, either. Recall that the average price of a new vehicle in Canada in 2025 was just a little less than $63,000. And for that, you get a handsome, high-performance hero that could reasonably fit into your garage without requiring too many sacrifices of you. It all makes for a very convincing package that could easily make you wonder: “Is this even a bad decision?”
Specifications
Make, Model, Trim
2026 BMW M240i xDrive Coupe
Base Price
$62,900
A/C Tax
$100
Destination Fee
$3,470
Price as tested
$83,820
Make
BMW
Model
M240i xDrive Coupe
Year
2026
Optional Equipment
$17,450 — Premium Enhanced Package, $5,200; M Enhanced Track Package, $3,500; M Performance Exhaust, $3,000; Oyster Vernasca Leather w/Contrast Stitching, $1,900; Parking Assistant Plus incl. Surround View, $1,000; M Sport Pro Package, $900; Thundernight Metallic paint, $900; Active Cruise Control w/ Stop and Go, $800; Brushed Aluminum Trim, $250.
Engine Displacement
3.0L
Engine cylinders
Turbocharged inline-six
Peak hp
382 hp @ 5,800-6,500 rpm
Peak torque
369 lb-ft @ 1,800-5,000 rpm
Fuel economy
10.3/7.3/9.0 L/100 km (city/hwy/comb)
Cargo space
390 L
All Articles
See all
2026 BMW i4 M60 Review
No matter how it’s powered, this is a sport sedan at heart — and a BMW one at that.

2026 BMW R 1300 RT Review
A dynamic, shapeshifting, long-distance touring bike.

2026 BMW M340i 50Jahre Edition Review
A special edition marks 50 years of the 3 Series.

























